Appeal court win for company directors

Creditors need greater protection following the appeal ruling at the Supreme Court for England, Wales and Northern Ireland…

The UK Supreme Court recently dismissed a claim for a law change that would force company directors to take creditors into account at the first sign of insolvency.

Instead, the Supreme Court upheld the current law. As a result, directors only need to prioritise creditors when company insolvency is highly likely. Under the current ruling, company directors do not have to act immediately. A director’s duty to creditors only triggers when a company:

  • Becomes insolvent
  • Is on the brink of insolvency

In a recent case, debt collector BTI filed a lawsuit against Scottish paper maker Sequana.

Supreme Court blow for creditors

The action sought to reclaim a £188m dividend paid to Sequana by subsidiary company AWA. Although AWA was solvent at the time, the company had long-term pollution liabilities, which made insolvency a likely outcome.

BTI brought a claim against the AWA directors who allowed the payment. They argued that by making the payment, the directors had breached their duty to protect creditors’ interests. BTI’s appeal was, however, dismissed.

The Supreme Court ruled that considering the circumstances when AWA paid the dividend, the company’s directors were not obliged to:

  1. Consider creditors
  2. Act in creditors’ interests

Pro-director ruling

The Supreme Court’s findings should please directors as they suggest that creditors only need to be considered if:

  • Insolvency is imminent
  • It becomes more likely than not the company will become insolvent

However, this move will annoy creditors who may justifiably argue the ruling:

  • Ignores the risks creditors face
  • Gives directors a licence to do as they please

And there is one important question: how does anyone determine when a company is on the brink of insolvency? The Supreme Court’s ruling did not specify. The precise moment that triggers this duty remains unknown and seemingly at the discretion of directors.

Urgent Call to Action: Have You Invested in Beech Holdings (Manchester) Ltd?


If you or anyone you know has invested in Beech Holdings (Manchester) Ltd, it’s time to take action immediately and get in touch. The Situation…

Read More

Bankruptcy Annulment: A Fresh Start for Financial Recovery


Bankruptcy is often viewed as a last resort for individuals overwhelmed by debt, offering a path to financial relief but also leaving a significant mark…

Read More

Castle Trust and Management Services Ltd- The Big Problem for the Gibraltar Financial Services Commission


The collapse of Castle Trust and Management Services Ltd (CTMS) has raised serious questions aboutthe role and effectiveness of the Gibraltar Financial Services Commission (GFSC)…

Read More

Construction Debt: A Major Issue for the Industry


When it comes to construction debt, debt recovery for specialist contractors isn’t just about recouping losses; it’s about survival. Cash flow is the lifeblood of any business.…

Read More