R3 Wrong to Blame Cable’s Insolvency Service for Fall in Company Director Disqualifications

The UK’s leading professional association for insolvency and business recovery specialists, R3, claims dodgy company directors are escaping punishment because the Insolvency Service (IS) is more concerned with meeting targets than launching complex investigations.

According to R3, while the number of reports alleging director misconduct has doubled since 2003, during the same period there’s been a 20% reduction in the number of directors disqualified as a result of an IS investigation.

R3 accuse the IS of focusing on simple and routine cases, but I think the criticism is undeserved.

There’s been a recession, which helps to explain the increase in the number of insolvency practitioners reporting director misconduct; there’s a knock-on effect.

Moreover, other than allegations of wrongdoing, there are additional factors the IS must navigate before disqualifying a director.

The organisation is an under-funded executive agency of the Vince Cable-led Department for Business Innovation and Skills, which has been subject to severe cutbacks.

Even if they wanted to, the IS cannot follow up every case of misconduct with an investigation; it would be far too expensive.

The overriding decision on whether the IS follows-up a report of wrongdoing has to be a commercial one as the organisation has a limited budget; therefore only extreme cases will be subject to further investigation.

The IS doesn’t have an endless pot of money to commit to an infinite amount of investigations and prosecutions, and R3 should know this already so their assessment is more than a little baffling.

R3 must remember that investigations are labour and capital intensive, and the IS has to be mindful of how they commit taxpayers’ funds, particularly in such austere times.

Posted in

Beech Holdings (Manchester) Ltd – Currently Under Investigation


Beech Holdings (Manchester) Ltd (now called Manchester Property Developments Holdings Ltd) is a company self-described as a prominent residential developer and operator with a rich…

Read More
off plan property

Navigating Off-Plan Property Purchases: Your Guide to Recovery


Purchasing off-plan property can be an enticing prospect, offering a chance to secure a futureproperty at potentially lower prices and reap wonderful returns. However, the…

Read More

The Power of Unity: How Creditors’ Action Groups Can Help Recover Your Investments


Sometimes, when investments take a wrong turn, it can leave you feeling isolated,powerless, and hopeless. You might question your ability to fight back as an…

Read More

Debt Assignment: What You Need to Know


You may have heard the term “debt assignment” tossed around in the world of finance, but whatdoes it really mean? Simply put, debt assignment is…

Read More